Package Stolen? Here's What to Do Next

Your tracking alert says "Delivered," and the delivery photo shows your front door. But when you get home, the box isn't there.

An empty front porch with a phone notification saying a package was delivered to the front door.

Image: ZFLO

Unfortunately, this is a common, frustrating moment. Roughly 250,000 packages are stolen in the U.S. every day, and the holiday shipping rush gives porch pirates even more to choose from. The good news: in many cases, you can get a replacement, as long as you act quickly. Most retailers and carriers set time limits on claims.

Here's what to do, in order.

1. Make sure it's really gone

Before you assume the worst, check:

  • The delivery photo. Does it show your door, or someone else's?

  • Around your home: side doors, the garage, behind planters, the back porch.

  • Your mailbox, building mailroom, or front desk.

  • With neighbors. Misdeliveries to the house next door are common.

This can seem annoying, but most retailers will ask whether you checked all these places—and sometimes packages scanned "Delivered" show up a day later. If it's not there by the next day, move on to step 2.

2. Contact the seller first

Go to your order and look for a way to report a delivery problem. Many retailers will refund or replace a missing package, but more and more require proof that you really didn’t receive it. Be sure to have your delivery photo, order number, and tracking number ready to share.

3. File a claim with the carrier

Depending on the retailer's response, you may also need to contact the carrier. If it looks like a delivery error and not a theft, the retailer may help you file a claim with the carrier. But if you have a legit delivery photo, it may be hard to get recourse from the delivery company.

All major carriers offer ways to file a claim: USPS, UPS, FedEx, Amazon Logistics, or a regional carrier. Each has its own process and deadline, so check the carrier's site for the details.

4. Save the evidence

Keep everything in one place:

  • Tracking history and delivery confirmation

  • The delivery photo

  • Doorbell or security camera footage, with timestamps

  • Any alerts or notifications you received

You may need these for a refund, an insurance claim, or a police report.

5. Report it

We strongly recommend filing a report with your local police department — especially if you have footage or know that others in the neighborhood have also had packages go missing.

Even if you don't catch the thief or recover your package, it helps police know whether a neighborhood is being targeted.

If USPS delivered the package, you can also report it to the U.S. Postal Inspection Service online or by calling 1-877-876-2455. Postal inspectors only handle packages that were in USPS custody. For other carriers, contact the carrier and local police.

6. Check your coverage

You may have protection for a stolen package that you didn’t realize is there:

  • Credit card purchase protection. Many cards cover theft of recent purchases.

  • Renters or homeowners insurance. Package theft may be covered, though your deductible could be higher than the package's value.

  • Shipping insurance. If the sender insured the package, the claim may be quick.

Remedies vary by retailer, carrier, and payment method, so check each one's policy.

Next time: stop it before it happens

Getting your money back or replacing the stolen item is good. Not losing the package in the first place is better. Most protection methods tell you a package arrived or record the theft. Very few stop a thief in the act.

Read our guide to protecting your packages from porch pirates, including the four layers of package protection and which methods actually work.


Rebecca Edwards is a content strategist working with ZFLO Technologies. She spent more than a decade as Head of Editorial at SafeWise, where she led the site’s annual package theft research. Connect on LinkedIn

Next
Next

How to Protect Your Packages From Porch Pirates: What Actually Works